Search detnews.com
GO



Zip:
AP news updates
Does segregation hurt whites?

Do you believe segregation hurts whites? Tell us why or why not.

Yes 46% This poll has closed but your feedback is still welcome
No 53%

Add your comments on this topic by clicking here

Posted: Tue. Jan. 22, 2002 at 8:25 PM
From: Samantha Bader
City: Rochester Hills, Mi
E-mail: ShySammi@hotmail.com
Subject: segregation_whites
Comments: I orginally grew up in Birmangham and went to Birmingham schools, untill my freshman year when I transfered to Ferndale High School. I feel segregation hurts white people because they are unaware of were Black people are coming from. Before I went to Ferndale, I always thought Black and White people were the same with no differences. Untill I went to Ferndale were I learned that there is a cultural difference. Which when I talk to people of my age that have never had my experience, I hear a lot of comments such as why dont they move, they make it like that, they can get out if they want. Not understanding that these people are held down, buy society.

I must say the education at Birmingham was much higher of a standard. As I get older though I realize the chance to experience diversity was much better, and something I would rather have my child experience. It makes easier for me to understand people, and other cultures.


Posted: Tue. Jan. 22, 2002 at 11 :37 AM
From: Mark Case
City: Savannah, GA
Subject: segregation_whites
Comments: Sociologically and culturally, segregation allows whites to continue to live under the misguided perception that people are not equal. Blacks in Metro Detroit, for the most part live in deteriorating conditions while whites live in visibly better circumstances. Even some of the lower income pockets of white suburbia offer significantly better living conditions than blacks enjoy.

Many whites will allow themselves to believe that it is a matter of due privilege based on racial status. For this nation to narrow the racial chasm, whites must acknowledge the notion of human equality. They must see American culture for what it is, a decaying relic.

To revitalize our economy, our culture, and our future as the world's leader, we must endeavor to embrace our commonality and celebrate our diversity.

By the same token, the black culture must live by the same rules. For integration to be successful, blacks, whites and others must agree to some common cultural ground. Not only are we living in separate communities in segregated areas, but we are living in separate cultures with distinctly different values and norms.

Until we can agree on an American culture, divisions will grow. Divisions are good for no one. Look at what is happening in the world around us. Racial and religious divisions are destroying many of our international neighbors. If we are unable to live together, our future faces further decay and eventual downfall.


Posted: Mon. Jan. 21, 2002 at 6:55 PM
From: ed smith
City: sterling hieghts, mi
E-mail: lagunaman@netzero.net
Subject: segregation_whites
Comments: No segregation doesn't hurt whites. What no one has considered is that the main reason for segregation is that Detroit is a zoo. Most of the whites (my family and friends included) got out of there because of the crime and decreasing property values. Most people didn't leave because their neighbors were black, they left because the city was a zoo.

I am white and some of my best friends from the old hood were black. I am no racist either. Most of the serious crimes in Detroit(murder, rape, car jackings) are caused by African Americans. So whites got away from the city because most of the crimes were caused by blacks and unfortunately that is what has led to most of the segregation in my opinion.

If blacks are law abiding and good citizens, they are welcome anywhere in my book. Civil rights leaders should focus on the black criminal element and not cry racism when something controversial happens against African Americans.


Posted: Mon. Jan. 21, 2002 at 6:55 PM
From: Ralph Ward
City: Cincinnati, OH
E-mail: rward@cinci.rr.com
Subject: segregation_whites
Comments: The only way segregation has hurt whites is that it limits the opportunity for them to understand blacks.


Posted: Mon. Jan. 21, 2002 at 6:10 PM
From: Rodney Williams
City: Lathrup Village, MI
E-mail: rwilliams@recruiteracademy.com
Subject: segregation_whites
Comments: I think it hurt's whites because they truly miss out on learning and understanding different cultures especially those of Blacks, whom they have to interact with mostly at work and in school. The one's who are affected the most are the children and young people, they have no sense of what other races or cultures are all about. It makes for a pretty narrow view of the real world. It also foster the mistrust and misunderstanding of people of different races.

This is why so many people make stupid comments about other races or don't try to get to know other people of other races becasue they have always live sperately and they don't feel the need to change now. In the long run we are all hurt by segragation both white and black.


Posted: Mon. Jan. 21, 2002 at 5:38 PM
From: Crystal P.
City: Oak Park, MI
E-mail: N2Cakes2001@cs.com
Subject: segregation_whites
Comments: I don't think segregation hurts whites because whites are statistically better off than blacks as far as income, education and housing. I also believe that whites are better financial planners than blacks, thus causing them to benefit more than blacks.


Posted: Mon. Jan. 21, 2002 at 2:22 PM
From: dave
City: westland, mi
Subject: segregation_whites
Comments: along with segregation comes a need for special help for minorities"affimative action and other special help" it hurts whites by giving away jobs to people, affectly taking them away from somebody else also City's surrounding those that are not doing well have to pay in crime, drugs , even death.

God help those americans who get nothing handed to them and still have to compete in a declining economy. Our system is a ever spinning downward mess.

Remember who told you 3/4's of welfare fuels the fire which eventually brings us down


Posted: Sun. Jan. 20, 2002 at 10:18 PM
From: Katrina Dixon
City: Detroit, MI
E-mail: kat4kids@aol.com
Subject: segregation_whites
Comments: The loss is lack of opportunity to understand other races."A People drown due to ignorance".


Posted: Sun. Jan. 20, 2002 at 3:49 PM
From: Dorothy J. Brown
City: W. Bloomfield, MI
E-mail: dorjbrown@aol.com
Subject: segregation_whites
Comments: I believe there is a premium whites pay in terms of higher rent, cost of homes, etc. for the priviledge of living apart from blacks. In addition:

- White adults and their children lack understanding and insights regarding people who are different and are less tolerant of race and other diversity factors than those who live in a more integrated community.

- Those who earn higher wages pay for those who are deprived of quality education, healthcare, and other things that contribute to people being poor.

- People who have a shot at life's offerings are less likely to get into trouble than those who have nothing to lose.

- White organizations who do not embrace diversity miss out on the talent and gifts people or color have to offer when race is a factor in the hiring and promotion of their staff.


Posted: Thu. Jan. 17, 2002 at 12 :30 PM
From: james walker
City: grand rapids, mi
Subject: segregation_whites
Comments: The wealth that white Americans have looted over the centuries has insulated them from the problems they have created for other races. Segregation is the same as apartheid and history shows the oppressed usually have to break a few windows before the oppressers realize the extent of their selfishness.


Posted: Wed. Jan. 16, 2002 at 1:38 PM
From: Brian
City: Boston, ma
Subject: segregation_whites
Comments: Since Blacks commit most of the violent crime in this country (see Duke.com "The Color of Crime"), and use welfare and social programs far beyond their population, it is not surprising that most White people are in favor of segregation. Otherwise, "White flight" would not be the biggest factor in the American housing market today.

Besides, as much as the average Negro hates White Americans, why would anyone want to subject themselves to all of the hatred Whites face living in non-White areas?


Posted: Wed. Jan. 16, 2002 at 1:32 PM
From: John Holt
City: Bethlehem, PA
E-mail: artist59@hotmail.com
Subject: segregation_whites
Comments: All I want to know is why does integration have to be forced down our throats? I like living in a white neighborhood and I see nothing wrong with that. I wish that the government and liberal organizations would get off our backs and let us live where we want.


Posted: Wed. Jan. 16, 2002 at 8 :18 AM
From: Eric Palmer
City: Detroit, MI
E-mail: elpalmer@prodigy.net
Subject: segregation_whites
Comments: Just as in any situation, when you control and you want to impress your essence onto what you control, you seek no input from any other "diverse" source. This world, country, and state has been controlled by "whites" so to the point that societal standards are based on what they feel are right. No input from "other thans." With that said, considering that the City of Detroit has not be "controlled" by whites since 1971-72 their "essence" has not been, recently, impressed upon the city, a major American city mind you, and now segregation is a problem to the established white society that includes governmental and business leaders as well as the media. But, in reality, it is not.


Posted: Tue. Jan. 15, 2002 at 2:02 PM
From: Pradeep Srivastava
City: Detroit, MI
E-mail: pradeepscool@hotmail.com
Subject: segregation_whites
Comments: Why would segregation hurt whites, when whites choose to move away from predominantly black neighborhoods and can afford to do so?


Posted: Tue. Jan. 15, 2002 at 1:57 PM
From: Lesley R. Goins
City: Detroit, MI
Subject: segregation_whites
Comments: Segregation hurts everyone, especially those who do not have, but who see others as having everything. When you grow up knowing that you already have three strikes against you, many times you don't try and you fall by the wayside.

Contrary to many people who live outside of the city, life is hard for a large number of poor people in Detroit. That is not to say there are not many success stories, but the vast majority of people are living at or below the poverty line.

Where there is poverty, there is want, where there is want, there is crime to get what you see others have.

All people from the inner city need is a break. You can't take all the business and industry from the inner city and expect the people to survive. We don't have a good transportation system, the infrastructure of the city is crumbling, and there are few jobs available in the inner city. I know that we have a new mayor, and hopefully, things will change. But change is going to take time, and Detroit needs help. Detroit needs business and industry to help those who are unemployed or underemployed.

As to the affect on those in the suburbs the affect is a moral one. There is no difference in races. Race is not a fact, it is only a word made up to categorize people. We are basically all the same, whether we like to admit it or not. If one believes in God, one knows that we all come from the same seed. God didn't make two Adams and Eves one set in an inner city and the other in a suburban Garden of Eden. God made only one pair. Whether we like it or not, we are the same. Not all sisters and brothers look alike, but that is what we are under the skin. So instead of looking at minorities with distrust, look at them as a brother or a sister or perhaps a potential friend.

Stereotypes of people have persisted over many centuries, but have proven to be wrong. You can't believe things you hear, you have to make a conscious effort to find out for yourself. Not all people of any group or culture are good or bad, and we should not judge all people by the deeds of some.


BACK TO "WHAT OTHERS ARE SAYING" | NEXT

Site Index
Homepage
Search
CyberSurveys
News Talk
Autos Talk
Sports Talk
Lions Talk
Pistons Talk
Tiger Talk
Wings Talk
Tech Talk
Horoscope
Hot Sites
Lottery
Recommendations
Weather
Staff

News
Autos
Insider
Consumer
Joyrides
Business
Careers
Columnists
Commuting
Detroit History
Editorials
Health
Metro/State
Livingston
Macomb
Oakland
Wayne
On Detroit
Nation/World
Obituaries
Death Notices
Politics
Real Estate
Religion
Schools
Special Reports
Technology

Sports
Sports Home
Lions/NFL
Red Wings/NHL
Pistons/NBA
Shock/WNBA
Tigers/Baseball
MSU
U-M
More Colleges
Golf Guide
High Schools
Motor Sports
More Sports
Outdoors
Scoreboards

Entertainment
Entertainment
Casino Guide
Movie Finder
TV Listings
Crossword

Homestyle
Homestyle home
Decorating
Food
Gardening
Home Improvement
Home Life
Home Tech
Wine Report

Photo Galleries
Sports
Red Wings
Lions
Autos
Joyrides
News
History